A discussion on Stress, PTSD, Depression, Psychological and Mental Health issues in the Military reminded me of a spoof I had written many years ago in my series of stories on Military Medicine on MENTAL HEALTHCARE – MILITARY STYLE.
Dear Reader:
I am posting the spoof once more for your perusal and comments.
_____________
MENTAL HEALTHCARE – MILITARY STYLE
Musings of a Veteran by Vikram Karve
_____________
DEPRESSION
During my days in the Navy – there was no concept of “depression”.
You were either “sane” – or – you were “insane”.
It was all “black-and-white” – no grey area.
There was nothing “in-between” sanity and insanity.
You were either “normal” – or you were “crazy”.
And – if they thought that you were “crazy” – they branded you a “psycho”.
Then – they sent you to the psychiatric ward – to be dealt with by the Military Psychiatrists (called “Shrinks” in Navy Parlance).
Recently I read an interesting discussion on Social Media regarding Lifestyle Diseases suffered by Military Personnel (including Mental Issues, Depression, PTSD etc)
This reminded of a fictional spoof which I wrote sometime ago – on Mental Health Care – titled – “How to Cure Depression” (Military Style).
Dear Reader:
Here is the “Humor in Uniform” spoof – for you to read, have a laugh and ponder over…
Before you start reading – let me remind you that this is a humorous spoof – tongue-in-cheek satire – “Humor in Uniform” – pure fiction – just for fun and humor – no offence is meant to anyone – so take it with a pinch of salt and have a laugh.
____________
HUMOR IN MILITARY MEDICINE SERIES – PART 7
MENTAL HEALTHCARE – MILITARY STYLE
Continued from Part 6 – Medical Category url: https://karve.wordpress.com/2018/09/19/humor-in-military-medicine-part-6-medical-category/
___________
HOW TO CURE DEPRESSION – MILITARY STYLE
Nowadays – I am surprised to see counselling and therapy being practised in a big way.
When I was in school – around 55 years ago – in the 1960’s – I don’t remember having any Counsellors in my schools.
Later – Schools had Vocational or Guidance Counsellors – who tested aptitude and advised students on selection of educational-streams/courses/career-choice which were in harmony with their aptitude.
Now – I understand – that apart from Vocational Guidance Counsellors – some schools even have Psychological Counsellors.
I heard that even youngsters go for “therapy” to counsellors for various problems – the main problem being “Depression”
I do not know whether I have ever suffered from “depression”.
In fact – I don’t even know what “depression” exactly is.
Yes – I feel “sad” and “low” at times.
Yes – I am a “moody” person – and – I have mood swings.
Is it “depression”…?
Am I “depressed”…?
I really don’t know.
Maybe – “Ignorance is Bliss”.
In boarding school – in college – and – later in the Navy (where I spent my entire career):
There was no concept of “depression”.
You were either “sane” – or – you were “insane”.
It was all black-and-white – no grey area.
There was nothing “in-between” sanity and insanity.
You were either “normal” – or you were “crazy”.
And – if they thought that you were “crazy” – they branded you a “psycho”.
And – and they sent you to the psychiatric ward – to be dealt with by the Military Psychiatrists
(Psychiatrists were called “Shrinks” in Navy Parlance)
Yes – in Navy Jargon of yesteryear – jocularly – all Doctors were called “Quacks” – and – all Psychiatrists were called “Shrinks”.
Those days – in the Navy (Military) – since “depression” was not recognised as a malady – it seems that there was no concept of psychological counselling or therapy.
Well – at least I did not see any psychologists, counsellors or therapists in uniform.
So – how was depression “cured” or “managed” in the Military…?
Read on…
But – before you read on – please read the “disclaimer” below once more:
Disclaimer: This is a humorous spoof – tongue-in-cheek satire – “Humor in Uniform” – pure fiction – just for fun and humor – no offence is meant to anyone – so take it with a pinch of salt and have a laugh.
__________
Humor in Uniform
DEPRESSION “MANAGEMENT” – MILITARY STYLE
A Fictional Spoof By Vikram Karve
__________
NB: The generic terms “Fauji” and “Soldier” refer to all Military Personnel (Officers/Soldiers/Sailors/Airmen) – and – the term “Faujan” refers to all Military Wives.
___________
Sometime ago – I attended a Literary Festival in Pune.
There was a session on “Stereotypes” in Fiction.
The panelists decried the tendency to stereotype characters – especially in romantic fiction.
Among the panelists was an Army Wife (“Faujan”) – an accomplished author – who has written a successful novel on the Life of an Army Wife.
I candidly told her that – in her novel – she too had “stereotyped” her Army Officer “Hero”:
“Quintessential” Army Officer = “Tough Macho Man” + “Debonair Gentleman” + “Ideal Boyfriend” + “Super Husband” + “Perfect Father” …et al…
She agreed with me – that – at least in Indian Literature – most novels/movies with a military backdrop have a tendency to “stereotype” the Military Officer as the “ultimate impeccable superman” with all the perfect qualities.
Most Military Literature, Movies and Jingoistic Military Recruitment Advertisements reinforce such “stereotypes” of Army, Navy and Air Force Officers.
I have come across a few “Military Wife” Blogs (written by “Faujans”) – where – I have observed a tendency to stereotype the “Military Wife” – and – believe it or not – they have even stereotyped the “Military Girlfriend”.
Yes – there is a tendency to stereotype “Military Wives” too.
If you have served in military uniform – or – if you are married to a person who has served in uniform – you will know that Military Officers and Military Wives (“Faujis” and “Faujans”) are like most normal human beings.
Thanks to this stereotyping of the “Military Officer/Soldier” (“Fauji”) – there is a perception that “Faujis” are so physically robust and mentally tough – that it is not possible for “Faujis” to suffer from an “effeminate frailty” like “depression”.
The quintessential Military “Fauji” is supposed to be a “Tough Guy”.
_________
So:
A Military “Fauji” is expected to be at one of the two “macho” extremes:
1. Either he is supposed to be macho “compos mentis”.
or
2. He is supposed to go macho “berserk” – and run amok.
__________
In the military – there is no scope for “middle-of-the-road” sensitive fragilities like “depression”.
Things may be different now – but in the “good old days” – Mental Health was a simple “Black” and “White” matter:
Either – you were “sane”
Or – you were “insane”
There was nothing in between the two extremes.
Being “sensitive” or “emotional” was considered “un-militarily-like”.
There was no place for a “sentimental sissy” in the Military.
Such “mushy” traits were considered as a sign of effeminate weakness and indicated lack of OLQ (Officer Like Qualities).
The Military Motto was:
“Stop crying like a Woman…
You must take it like a Man…”
If you had an “emotional problem” – you had to “sort out” your own problem.
Or – you had to bear it with stoicism.
If you could not “sort out” your emotional problem – and – you were forced to endure your emotional problem with stoicism – two things could happen:
1. The emotional problem cured itself – and – in due course of time – you became okay.
or
2. The emotional problem worsened and metamorphosed into a psychiatric disorder – in which case – you were declared a “psycho”– and – sent to the psychiatrist.
____________
Things may have changed now – but – in the “good old days” – there was no concept of psychological counselling to alleviate emotional problems faced by “Faujis”.
In the earlier system of relying exclusively on psychiatric treatment – Military Officers/Soldiers were afraid to officially report their “emotional problems” to their superior officers – because – it would be presumed that they were suffering from “psychiatric disorders” – and – they would be sent to military hospitals for psychiatric treatment.
Once Officers/Soldiers were referred for psychiatric treatment – their medical category would be downgraded – and – thereafter – for the rest of their life in the service – they would suffer the stigma of being branded as “psycho” – and – their military careers would be ruined forever.
As it is – in those days – Military Officers/Soldiers were apprehensive of going to “specialist” doctors – since they wanted to avoid down-gradation of their “medical category” – which could affect their career prospects.
But – “Faujis” were most terrified of being referred to Psychiatrists – because – not only would your “medical category” be down-graded – but – you would be branded a “psycho” for your entire military career.
Hence – Officers/Soldiers suppressed their emotional distress.
Emotionally “depressed” Officers/Soldiers tried to “sort out” their emotional problem with “self-cure” – by adopting philosophical and spiritual self-help techniques like “positive thinking”, “meditation”, “prayer” etc.
Or – “Faujis” resorted to the Universal “Panacea” for all ills – Alcohol – which was provided at concessional rates to “Faujis”
Yes – Dear Reader:
Alcohol was considered as the macho “remedy” for “depression cure”.
“Self-Cure” or “Alcohol Cure” may have worked in some cases of “depression”.
But – if the emotionally distressed individual could not cure himself – this could ultimately result in serious ramifications like mental illness – or – even suicide – in extreme cases.
Sometime ago – in August 2017 to be precise – I read a news report that 310 Army Personnel had committed Suicide since 2014 – and there were 11 cases of Fratricide.
From time to time – there are news reports regarding the severe stress suffered by Military Personnel – like this recent report – Over Half of Army Personnel under Severe Stress.
Doesn’t this highlight the urgent need for psychological counselling/therapy facilities in the Armed Forces…?
During my Navy days – I do not recall any psychologists posted as counsellors on board Naval Ships – with whom officers/sailors could talk regarding their emotional problems.
The only “counsellors” available were your friends, your family – or – your superior officers – like it happened to the officer in the story below – titled “Depression Management”
Here is a story of how a “depressed” officer was “counselled” by his superior officer…
_____________
DEPRESSION MANAGEMENT (an apocryphal story)
During my early Navy days – around 45 years ago – in the 1970’s – we had a Senior Lieutenant on our ship – a frontline warship – a Whitby Class Frigate
(Those days you remained a Lieutenant till you completed 11 years of commissioned service when you were promoted to the rank of Lieutenant Commander)
This Senior Lieutenant had over 9 years commissioned service.
He had coined a maxim – which epitomized “Depression Management” in the Navy:
“EVERY “PROBLEM” IS A “MINOR PROBLEM”…”
and
“A “MINOR PROBLEM” IS “NO PROBLEM”…”
therefore
“EVERY “PROBLEM” is “NO PROBLEM”…”
I will repeat this Depression Management Maxim again:
Every problem is a minor problem – a minor problem is no problem – so – every problem is no problem…
Therefore – by this maxim – a Naval Officer or Sailor was not supposed to have a problem – especially – a personal problem.
But – was this possible…?
Here is the story of an Officer who had a problem…
__________
STORY OF THE “DEPRESSED” OFFICER
A young Navy Sub Lieutenant felt depressed.
So – the young Sub Lieutenant went to this same Senior Lieutenant (who was his direct boss) and said:
“Sir – I have a personal problem…”
The Senior Lieutenant promptly enunciated his favourite slogan:
“Every Problem is a “Minor Problem” – and – a “Minor Problem” is “No Problem” – so – you have “No Problem”…”
Then – the Senior Lieutenant scolded the Sub Lieutenant.
The Senior Lieutenant told the depressed Sub Lieutenant to stop behaving like a sissy.
The Senior Lieutenant said to the Sub Lieutenant:
“In the Navy – you sort out your own problems – you don’t go crying like a bloody Sissy to your Boss regarding your personal problems…”
After that – the Senior Lieutenant shouted at the Sub Lieutenant to “get lost” – to “vamoose” – to “bugger off” – and – the Senior Lieutenant rudely ordered the Sub Lieutenant to get on with his work.
In the evening – the distraught Sub Lieutenant tried to unburden himself by talking about his personal problem to his shipmates in the wardroom.
(A Naval Officers’ Mess is called Wardroom – both afloat on warships and ashore on stone frigates).
The depressed Sub Lieutenant told his “sob story” to his shipmates over a drink.
It was a simple “affair of the heart”.
The Officer had fallen in Love with a Girl from a Wealthy Business Family.
The girl’s parents were not interested in marrying their only daughter to a “penurious” Navy Officer.
In fact – the girl was the “only child” of her parents – and – she was the heir to their “business empire”
So – the parents had arranged a suitable “business match” for her daughter befitting their affluence and “status”
Of course – the “business marriage” of their daughter to the son of a business tycoon would help expand their “business empire” as well.
And – though the girl loved the Navy Officer – the girl did not have the courage to go against her parents’ wishes.
The depressed officer’s well-meaning shipmates “counselled” him over a drink in the Wardroom.
They advised him various courses of action to cure his depression.
Some suggestions given to the Sub Lieutenant were:
1. “Forget about her – just get another girl. If you want – I will introduce you to a sexy “fleet auxiliary” who is available at the moment…”
2. “Come on – drink up – forget her – and – by tomorrow – you will be fine. Alcohol cures everything…”
3. “Why are you crying like a bloody sissy…? You are a tough Naval Officer. Just go and sort out the matter yourself – just go there – pick up your girl – elope with her – and – get married…”
____________
Now – the depressed officer was deeply in love with the girl.
It was not possible for him to forget her.
Also – the distraught officer was in no mood to have a “lustful affair” with a “fleet auxiliary”.
So – the officer considered the third option:
Elope with the girl – and – get married.
In order to get himself ready for this third option – the “depressed officer” drank up – glass after glass of whisky – till – he was drunk to the hilt.
Then – fortified with alcohol-induced “Dutch Courage” – he drove down on his motorcycle to the girl’s house to “sort out the matter” – to elope with his girlfriend and get married to her.
Well – the officer may have been emotionally vulnerable – but – physically – he was a huge powerful hulk – and – in his wild drunken state – he looked very intimidating.
You can well imagine what must have happened – when the fearsome formidable “angry young man” – dangerously drunk and berserk – ran amok in a menacing manner.
He accosted the girl’s parents – and – he tried to forcibly abduct the girl and elope with her.
It was with great difficulty that they managed to overpower him with the help of the police – who handed him over to the Naval Police.
Well – in order to save him from big trouble – the easiest thing for the “powers-that-be” to do – was to fill up a psychiatric disorder form AFMSF-10 – and – refer the “depressed officer” for “psychiatric examination”.
(notwithstanding the fact that he would be branded a “psycho” for life and his Naval career would be ruined)
So – thanks to the “Depression Management” dictum of the Senior Lieutenant – and the amateur Navy Style “counselling” by his shipmates – the “depressed officer” landed up in the psychiatric ward – branded a “psycho” for life – his Naval career ruined.
___________
EPILOGUE
“Compassionate Psychological Counselling” versus “Harsh Psychiatric Treatment”
Well – you may think that this illustrative fictional story of an “affair of the heart” is a tall story – a yarn.
But – the fact of the matter is – that – especially in today’s world – Military Men (and even Military Wives) – “Faujis” and “Faujans” – they need “emotional sustenance” – to face the multitude of problems peculiar to the Armed Forces – especially pertaining to Soldiers deployed in combat situations and their families.
And – for this “emotional sustenance” – isn’t “compassionate psychological counselling” a better option than “harsh psychiatric treatment”…?
Isn’t prevention better than cure…?
Military Hospitals have “Military Psychiatrists” to “cure” those who have gone “crazy”.
But – what about “preventing” individuals from going “crazy”…?
In today’s modern times – I wonder if Military Units and Naval Ships have easily accessible “Military Psychologists” to counsel military personnel on issues like Stress, PTSD, Depression, Psychological and Mental Health issues – to prevent individuals from going “crazy”, being branded as “psychos” and sent to military hospitals for psychiatric treatment…?
Dear Reader – Isn’t prevention better than cure…?
__________
VIKRAM KARVE
Copyright © Vikram Karve
1. If you share this post, please give due credit to the author Vikram Karve
2. Please DO NOT PLAGIARIZE. Please DO NOT Cut/Copy/Paste this post
© vikram karve., all rights reserved.
Disclaimer:
- This story is a fictional spoof, satire, pure fiction, just for fun and humor, no offence is meant to anyone, so take it with a pinch of salt and have a laugh.
- All Stories in this Blog are a work of fiction. Events, Places, Settings and Incidents narrated in the stories are a figment of my imagination. The characters do not exist and are purely imaginary. Any resemblance to persons, living or dead, is purely coincidental.
Copyright Notice:
No part of this Blog may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical including photocopying or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the Blog Author Vikram Karve who holds the copyright.
Copyright © Vikram Karve (all rights reserved)
Link to my source post in my Blog Academic and Creative Writing Journal Vikram Karve: http://karvediat.blogspot.in/2017/10/mental-health-care-military-style-humor.html
This article is an abridged version of my article DEPRESSION MANAGEMENT aka PSYCHO posted by me online many times in my various blogs including at urls: http://karvediat.blogspot.in/2016/09/humor-in-uniform-depression-management.html and https://karve.wordpress.com/2018/01/24/humor-in-uniform-how-to-cure-depression/ and https://karve.wordpress.com/2016/09/16/military-psychology-for-emotional-sustenance-and-depression-management/ and http://karvediat.blogspot.in/2017/02/how-to-manage-mental-health-care.html and http://karvediat.blogspot.in/2017/05/how-to-cure-depression-military-style.html and https://karve.wordpress.com/2019/07/08/humor-in-uniform-psycho/ and https://karve.wordpress.com/2020/06/14/story-of-the-depressed-sub-lieutenant/ etc
© vikram karve., all rights reserved.